data-mm-id=”_7wco0m9da”>In the midst of the fallout from the Houston Astros' sign-stealing scandal, Major League Baseball had another juicy story this week. The New York Post first reported on Major League Baseball's proposal to increase its postseason format from 10 teams to 14, as well as increasing the wild card round from one game to three.The kicker? The playoff matchups would be decided not by seeding, but by way of a special televised draw to be aired the Sunday night the regular season ends. The team with the second-best record in its league would get their first choice of opponent in the wild card round from the remaining playoff teams, as the best team in the league would get an automatic first-round bye.The reaction from most within baseball was, shall we say, not complimentary.No idea who made this new playoff format proposal, but Rob is responsible for releasing it, so I’ll direct this to you, Rob Manfred. Your proposal is absurd for too many reasons to type on twitter and proves you have absolutely no clue about baseball. You’re a joke.— Trevor Bauer (@BauerOutage) February 11, 2020We're not gonna lie, it has some issues. Here are just three of them.1. There is such a thing as too much baseballConsider the first year of the Division Series, 1995. That was the year of the infamous "Baseball Network" partnership between ABC and NBC which saw Division Series games played simultaneously on a regional basis. Half of the country was locked out of seeing the famous Mariners-Yankees ALDS that year. Major League Baseball has gone out of its way to avoid this happening in the years since (though it has happened, remember when playoff games appeared on FX or ABC Family?), but the league is openly aiming to create a smorgasbord of postseason baseball with this new format. I could reach the level of the early rounds of March Madness. While that sounds nice in theory, where is all that baseball going to go? Major League Baseball only has so many television partners, and there's only so much time in the television schedule, especially with October being such a loaded month for sports in general. There are already problems with postseason games being broadcast exclusively on MLB Network, a channel outside the reach of most ordinary Joes.Not to mention, the World Series could potentially be pushed into mid-November, which could pose weather problems across most of the country.2. The World Series of .500 TeamsIn the early days of the Division Series format, when a wild card team won a World Series, it wasn't too out of the ordinary. Only the best wild card could enter the playoffs, and they were usually no fewer than five games behind the division winner, and sometimes held a better record than the weakest division winner in their respective league. This proposed playoff format, however, would open up the possibility of postseason play for teams that, shall we say, don't deserve it.For instance, in 2017, the Los Angeles Angels, Kansas City Royals, and Tampa Bay Rays, all sporting records of 80-82, would have ended up in a three-way tiebreaker for the final two wild card spots. For those who believe that there is no way that that kind of team would have a chance to make it through a grueling baseball postseason, remember the 2012 Los Angeles Kings, who won the Stanley Cup despite entering the playoffs as an eighth seed. Such things can happen.3. The DrawThe centerpiece of this proposed playoff system is the televised draw, which would be held on the Sunday at the end of the regular season. Where to start with this idea?Yes, the idea of the "draw" in sports is nothing new. The NCAA Basketball Tournament, World Cup, Champions League, and FA Cup all feature a similar system. However, all of those competitions feature dozens of entrants. Even under a potentially expanded playoff system, Major League Baseball has no need for an over-the-top spectacle such as this.On top of that, why give a team the power to choose its own opponent? This goes against the basic idea of playoff seeding, which is to pit the strongest against the weakest as a reward for being the strongest. It doesn't seem as though there will be much of a difference anyway, unless there are seriously mitigating circumstances, teams would always choose the opponent they would be most likely to beat up on.
Related Posts
Beckham to captain Galaxy
David Beckham will captain Los Angeles Galaxy for the first time in three years when they face Real Salt Lake on Saturday.The 35-year-old first took the role upon joining the Major League Soccer club in 2007.Beckham relinquished the job when he joined AC Milan on loan in 2009, with United States international Landon Donovan becoming skipper.But with Donovan away on international duty, the veteran Englishman a former Manchester United and Real Madrid player will captain the team at the Rio Tinto Stadium. I ll be proud to wear it, Beckham said, referring to captain s armband. It doesn t change the way I play. It s something you re very proud to wear, but you need more than one leader on the field. Galaxy head coach Bruce Arena felt Beckham was the natura…
Liverpool managing director Ian Ayre is adamant the club has a bright financial future despite posting a 20m pound loss last year.
The club s published accounts for July 2009 to June were the makings of previous owners Tom Hicks and George Gillett, widely despised by the Anfield faithful.
The report showed that rising revenues were undermined by an increase in debt, but Fenway Sports Group, who took over the club for 300m pounds in October, have injected 200m pounds of debt repayments into the club so far.
And Ayres is confident the club is now in good hands.
As much as we are all aware of the difficult circumstances surrounding these accounts and that period in the Club s history, everyone in the world can now see just how much has since been achieved…
Borussia Dortmund midfielder Ilkay Gundogan believes coach Thomas Tuchel has the squad strength to cope with their current injury woes ahead of Wednesday s visit to Darmstadt.
Tuchel saw his side struggle to break down 10-man Hoffenheim in their 3-1 win at Signal Iduna Park on Sunday, with Dortmund missing centre-backs Sokratis Papastathopoulos and Mats Hummels, while Gundogan was only fit for the second half after illness.
The likes of Marco Reus, Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang and Lukasz Piszczek all shook off injury or illness to feature as an initially lacklustre Dortmund eventually prevailed with three late goals after Sebastian Rudy had seen red for Hoffenheim.
It keeps Dortmund within eight points of leaders Bayern Munich amid a hectic fixture schedule t…
Ghana coach Kwesi Appiah is eager to avoid injuries in their final friendly before the FIFA World Cup against South Korea on Monday.
Appiah s men face South Korea at Sun Life Stadium in Miami as they finish their preparations for Ghana s tournament opener against the United States next Monday.
Ghana reached the World Cup quarter-finals in South Africa in 2010, but face a tough task if they are to replicate that feat in Brazil, having also been drawn in Group G alongside Germany and Portugal.
A number of teams have suffered high-profile injuries in the lead up to the competition, with group rivals Germany seeing Marco Reus ruled out due to an ankle problem suffered in last Friday s 6-1 win over Armenia.
And Appiah is keen to ensure that he has a full squad of pla…
Germany head coach Joachim Low has called for clarity in the controversy over doping allegations levelled at Russia s 2014 World Cup squad.
A report in the Mail on Sunday claimed that Russia s 23-man squad at the finals in Brazil, along with another 11 footballers, are people of interest to officials at the heart of the probe into state-sponsored doping in Russia.
FIFA is still investigating the claims, which relate to players mentioned in the McLaren Report, which last year claimed more than 1,000 Russian sportspeople benefitted from a highly organised state-doping scheme, described as corruption on an unprecedented scale that led to a ban on Russian athletes competing at the Rio Olympics.
Both FIFA and Russian officials have pointed out none of their players ha…
Jeremy Toulalan is set to move to Bordeaux after his request to be released by Monaco was accepted.
Former France international Toulalan joined Monaco from Malaga in 2013 and had one more season remaining on his contract.
However, the club from the principality agreed to the captain s request for a move to Bordeaux, with the Nantes-born player citing a desire to move closer to his hometown.
The 32-year-old will arrive in the south west next week for a medical and to sign a deal with Jocelyn Gourvennec s team.
I spent three wonderful seasons with Monaco and I am proud to have contributed to the club s return to the forefront of the French and European stage, he said in a statement.
It is time for me to take on a different challenge that will also…
On the last day of transfer window, there was a lot of activity from Brighton and Hove Albion, but one of their moves was particularly interesting. The Seagulls had signed Jurgen Locadia in January 2018 from PSV Eindhoven in a deal that was worth just under 15 million pounds. But since then, the Dutch forward has not done very well for the Premier League side and he was loaned to Hoffenheim last summer.
But now Brighton recalled him from a loan and not for them to give him a new chance, but rather to sell him elsewhere. It was reported a few days ago that FC Cincinnati are interested in Locadia ahead of the start of the new Major League Soccer season.
Cincinnati want to make him one of their star players and offer him a Designated Player deal, whilst Brighton see this a…
Douglas Costa, Emre Can and Daniele Rugani all scored their first goals of the season as Juventus eased to a 3-0 Serie A win over struggling Chievo on Monday, despite Cristiano Ronaldo having a penalty saved.
Massimiliano Allegri s men were comfortable throughout in Turin and kept their healthy nine-point lead at the Serie A summit following Napoli s win over Lazio, though things would have been even more comprehensive had Ronaldo been accurate from the spot.
Although the visitors started positively, Juve still managed to take an early lead in style through Costa, before Can made it 2-0 late in the half – the Germany international scoring for the first time since joining from Liverpool.
Ronaldo wasted the chance to extend the advantage in the 52nd minute, thou…
Trevoh Chalobah has been rewarded for his excellent start to the season with a new four-and-a-half-year contract at Chelsea.
The 22-year-old defender has become an important part of Thomas Tuchel s squad this season, featuring in 10 games in all competitions after an impressive debut in the UEFA Super Cup final win over Villarreal in August.
He became the second youngest player to score on his Premier League debut for Chelsea when he struck against Crystal Palace that month and was on target again versus Southampton in October.
Having joined the Chelsea academy at the age of eight and spent the past three seasons out on loan at Ipswich Town, Huddersfield Town and Lorient respectively, Chalobah was elated to have tied himself to the Blues until 2026.
…
Aubameyang relishing Arsenal reunion as Chelsea boss Potter says World Cup puts players in ´tricky p
Chelsea boss Graham Potter admits every player with World Cup aspirations is in a tricky position as domestic football continues just days before teams fly to Qatar.
The Blues are waiting on news of Ben Chilwell s hamstring injury, as he headed for a scan on Friday amid fears the muscle is torn, which would rule him out of England s plans.
Potter understands players have concerns about suffering injuries at such an unfortunate moment, but will demand his squad hold nothing back in Sunday s Premier League meeting with Arsenal.
Chelsea striker Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang is poised to face his former club, and unlike many of his team-mates does not need to worry about the World Cup, which starts on November 20, having retired from international football within months …